Share This Page:

  

Marines 'violent bullying' probed

General Military Chat. New to the forums? Introduce yourself, Who are you and where are you from?
flighty
Guest
Guest

Post by flighty »

harry hackedoff wrote:I think some of us are missing the point here, ffs :evil:
Just so you don`t miss it again.......
Doc LEFT A TIDEMARK IN AUNTY JAYNES BATH
Shock Horror! :o

What a minging Matelot he is :roll:

Next time he stays Jayney, get him to sign the Bath Book, whatever that is :-? :P
Hope you aren't taking the rip, Monsieur Hackedouef. :o

And, for the record, Doc was the perfect house guest and he is welcome here any old time he likes. :D

Aitch ...... same applies to you and yours, mucker ...... see if you can stand the pace! :o :o :o :o
Doc
Guest
Guest

Post by Doc »

Says it all really!

Just had words with my old man, he was dripping on about the reports in the Press of recent events. I asked him what his problem was and he went off on one about standards and why on earth are grown men naked and drinking!

Now my old man "runs" the local rugby club and last season after a rough game full of fights, the post match piss up kicked off. Drinking games were being played and some players were naked. A fight reupted between teams and they trashed the upstairs bar!

I reminded him of events and his response at the time "well boys will be boys and they were only unwinding after a dirty game in which the other team were bad sports and deserved all they got!"

My response "so if a bunch of marines return from a 6 month operational tour of a war zone and decide to have a party and unwind away from the public and drink alot and a few fists are thrown as they unwind thats a huge problem, whilst a rugby team who did similar for reasons of a stressful 80 minute GAME are ok!"

Fark you News of the World and the Daily Mirror, I may have only been an attached matelot, but Im proud as fark of serving with the RM and Id entrust my life to anyone wearing the Globe and laurels on their head!

All this from a paper that condons football players shagging two essence super models in a hotel room but posts pics of the models and how to get cheap porn vids on the same page!

I think the British Press need to look at their own moral standing before they judge the lads who fight to give them the freedom to publish shite they earn millions out of!!!!!!!! :evil:

Im immensly proud to have served on unit strength in 3 units of 3 Cdo Brigade RM, have friends who are and were bootnecks and to have stood naked at many a banyan!
Last edited by Doc on Tue 29 Nov, 2005 8:54 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Wholley
Guest
Guest

Post by Wholley »

Yet another thread hi-jacked between Herr Hackedoof and #6.
And we wonder why peeps are leaving? :evil:
flighty
Guest
Guest

Post by flighty »

To add to that, I was thunderstruck by the kick in the gob delivered to that poor bloke and I hope the git responsible gets all that is coming to him.

On the other hand, aside from the numbers involved, similar stuff has gone on at No 6 all in the name of hi-jinx ..... but on a much smaller scale and with far fewer folk naked. :o

I do, however, have a nearly-beside-himself-Artistic person here at the mo who really, really is farked off by the implications of the press coverage.

Doing my level best but Doc and H_N ....... please stand by for an early trip to Cheshire. :o

Jayne xx
Marina
Member
Member
Posts: 730
Joined: Wed 26 Mar, 2003 6:22 pm
Location: London

Post by Marina »

I thought those guys were auditioning for a new adaption of D H Lawrence's 'The lovers', the Oliver Reed and Alan Bates roles !

Its a right turn off with those dangly bits !! Why can't they do it with their trousers on ? :-?
Doc
Guest
Guest

Post by Doc »

Naked Marine in Yomp shock!!

Image


:lol: :lol: :lol:

Yep he's an ex-bootneck, and errr.......... so's she! :o :lol:
taff
Member
Member
Posts: 4
Joined: Tue 22 Feb, 2005 8:41 am
Location: south wales

Post by taff »

You can see their reasons for wanting to have a pu if they've been away on tour to let off some steam but why were those 2 supposed NCO'S encouraging the 2 to have a ruck??, & more so why on earth did they have to dress up????. Call me naive but when that NCO was putting his mini skirt & wig on didn't he have a moment of clarity & think what exactly am I doing. Yes he was probably pissed but you still have the presence of mind to realise what your doing & the same goes for the surgeon weirdo. It did seem apparent that one of the two was more aggressive & perhaps both did want to fight & if so the NCO'S should have just made sure it didn't get out of hand but instead you can clearly see that the both are loving it, the strange surgeon is pacing up & down getting redicilously excited & the "St. Trinian" is relishing getting them to fight in different ways. So what is the explanation for that. Also NCO's are supposed to guide Marines & gain the respect of Marines through their leadership, these Marines aren't going to respect these NCO's after seeing this & especially after one of them knocking their oppo out!!!!. I know I'm maybe being over the top here & as a civvie possibly not entitled to comment, but I just think that generally people think so much of the Marines, that seeing this people are going to be really shocked that "the elite" act like this. The Marines is all about teamwork & trust in your fellowes, surely experiencing this is going to seriously question that. In conclusion, you'll be glad to know, I think that this could have an effect on recruitment figures. Some who were possibly thinking about wanting to join a professional & committed organisation might think if this is what happens then I'm not really interested. Yes everyone says it's an isolated incident, but how isolated is it ???????????????????
Doc
Guest
Guest

Post by Doc »

Picture the scene, Rugby match...gets abit heated, and we know what that means in Wales Taff (Im Welsh aswell). Post game piss up and some turn nasty. Ive heard and seen older men and women excuse the behaviour as rugby lads doing what rugby lads do. And they dress up and you can go to Cardiff any Weekend night and see lads dressed up and both sexes kicked 7 shades of shit out of each other due to alcohol. Excuses are various such as "hard week at work" "hard game of rugby" "it was the alcohol I aint usually like that" etc etc.

Now lets say you had just had a hard week at work and drank a bottle at home, pissed in your wardrobe and woke to find the lounge a mess with takeaway all over the place and your asleep upside down in the washing machine. We've all had them drunken moments we try to forget about and if we are honest most of them moments make for good chat in the pub weeks, months if not years later.

Now lets say you've been in the front line in Iraq, seen your oppos blown to shit and heard that one of your best mates died in a helicopter crash. You've been sober for all that time and couldnt let out the grief because you were patrolling Basra and shitting yourself that the next turn you make in your landrover could trigger an IED and blow you to shit.

You come back and the tension grief and relief finally lets go. Your options are to go down town and kick the shit out of the first civvy who gobs off, or have a party in your "home" and yes it is there home. Behind the fence, paid for monthly and not in the public eye. You get dressed up as rugby lads do, you play drinking games as rugby lads do and the mixture of it all means it goes over the top. Some characters over step the line and they are being delat with. But lets not lose sight of the fact that this was a private party with willing attendees. I know they are willing because Ive been there and done it. When you spend all your working life in uniform and even your off time in the unofficial uniform of jeans KSBs and tshirts, you unwind. Theres lots of excuses but dnt lose the fact this was private, fun, mad, pissed, tension relieving and wether you like it or not the best way to undo what we ask these elite lads to do.

We ask these lads to go into harms way, and they do it without hesitation. I read alot from all members on here that in War your there because of your oppo and Queen and country goes out of the window. In my experience that is so, when the bullets start flying. On the trip out and during the build up you are there for the immense pride you have in your unit corps and country.

These lads stand the line and say no one will pass to harm the UK, so that muppets in the press can utilise that freedom to slag of the very people who live and die protecting it.

So what if they get dressed up and get pissed, its there choice because its a free country and was done behind the fence in their home! Maybe we should send some cameras into private homes around the country and print what goes on!!!!

The SNCOs who assaulted the lad were out of order yes. The whole party wasnt. The RM and the RN dress up to go ashore and party, its been going on for years, Ive dressed as a woman, braveheart, dalamtion dog, toga etc etc etc. Its fun its a laugh and its doesnt do any harm.

Next time your in a rugby club and two teams are kicking off, half naked drinking beer from buckets and having a right old hoot, then take a pic on your mobile and send it to the News of the World in disgust. If you dont want to do that then why are you condoning similar behaviour in men who have just been to hell and back and who are doing it in private.

Bullying isnt tollerated, and nor is the build up of stress and not allowing what young men do in all walks of life and that is to get pissed.

If this has affected people enough not to join up then I would say these characters havent got what it takes to pick up pieces of a dead oppo, or put rounds down in a hot situation when your life depends on it. And dont say its different because it farking well isnt. Its all part of it, you get stressed you unwind, and if the local bank manager lets off steam after a busy week by sinking a few shots watching telly at home then men who are trained to kill, do kill and protect us all from the monsters of this world have the right to do it a litle bit differently.

The Armed forces are immensly proud of who they are and what they do and for whom they do it for, bullies when found out get short change from the lads, I know as Ive seen bullies at work and the unit then sorting these weaklings out, within proper channels. Its one big family and all families have rotten eggs in them, luckily the Corps finds them out and sends them packing.

I was once party to a fight in Plymouth after a tour, 4 of us were set upon for no reason by about 15 civvies, we defending ourselves and one of them fell hitting his head on the pavement, he swallowed his tongue and as his mates ran off into the night it was us who saved his life and got him to hospital. Thats the RM I know, they'd give you the shirt off their backs even after you repeadetly stab them in that back.

The Corps will survive this, and all the crap thats coming out of it, because they are better than the ones slagging them off.

Now this debate will no doubt go on for awhile, but thankfully the only opinions I get offended by are from people I respect and value. Thats not to say you cant have your say,as you can, because the men you are slagging have defended your right to free speeach, and my dont you kick the arse out of it! :evil:
taff
Member
Member
Posts: 4
Joined: Tue 22 Feb, 2005 8:41 am
Location: south wales

Post by taff »

I do understand what your saying & I am in no position to comment. Don't be mislead by thinking I don't respect these men because I have the upmost respect for people who are mentally strong enough & who can deal with the pressures of being RM. There's just a lingering feeling of disappointment. Wouldn't other forces around the world see this & think, "what" ?????, or perhaps not because it's quite normal & they do the same, again I don't know I'm just saying what I think, maybe I shouldn't. Perhaps I'm overly sensitive & that things shock me too easily, that's why I'd never understand or be able to cope with everything that comes with being recognised as one of the world's elite. I'll shut up now.
dwarfy
Member
Member
Posts: 511
Joined: Wed 23 Nov, 2005 12:05 pm
Location: somerset

Post by dwarfy »

[quote="taff"] In conclusion, you'll be glad to know, I think that this could have an effect on recruitment figures. Some who were possibly thinking about wanting to join a professional & committed organisation might think if this is what happens then I'm not really interested. quote]

To be honest if having seen what the Royal Marines have done throughout their whole history and especially during the recent years, in Iraq and Afghanistan if a possible recruit is put off by three seconds of film in what otherwise would have looked like a laugh, then really is that a loss? If they can not see past this and see the big picture,then something is not right. I am at a loss as to how ANYONE could question the Corps proffessionalism and commitment. They were the first conventional troops in to Iraq during Op Telic, and paramount in the taking of the Al Faw Peninsular and involved hugely throughout with great success. Since then they have been back on many occasions, risking thier lives every day in many cases for a wage far less than the average civilian, something that is lost in thier minds purely because of their "commitment" to their job and their oppo's.

Lets not forget, this was NOT bullying, and those involved were so on their own accord, one man went too far.ONE MAN. Other than 3 seconds of footage the rest of it, in both vidios was just men who have a very hard job to do, letting off steam amoungst themselves in their own time in thier own home, and it did not effect anyone else. Its the drug addicts that mug old ladies and steal kids bikes, and the youths that rip up town centres that people should be complaining about, not the men who defend our freedoms. These events harmed no one.
Doc
Guest
Guest

Post by Doc »

Taff, we all have the right to voice an opinion mate. Im not ripping into you personally, its just the PC brigade and the press wheeling out "officers" who havent even served with the Corps to give their unqualified opinion on matters that dont concern them.

You wont find a better bunch of blokes, that I can assure you, and I wasnt a bootneck, I was a matelot and the butt of many a joke and wind up from Royal, fry the lot I say! bunch of cults! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Just remember this was a 2 minute video clip taken by a phone that has suppossedly been edited and was filmed back in May. The party had been going on all day and toward the end of the clip the schoolgirl and another bloke went to the aid of the zonked out lad on the deck. What we didnt see was the aftermath and what happened to the "medic". He's probably in the deepest shit imaginable right now. Not because of the party but because he assaulted another person and was a complete prong.

So two minutes out of a whole day, of a whole week, of a whole year, of the entire history of the corps. Why have peoples opinions changed??? Who runs this country and your brains?? Dodgy tabloid press condoning lads behaviour on one page and selling porn and phonesex the next???

Read the forums Taff, Im sure you'll find that whilst this topic is a hot potatoe, like the rest of the forces theres alot else going on.

Welcome aboard bud
taff
Member
Member
Posts: 4
Joined: Tue 22 Feb, 2005 8:41 am
Location: south wales

Post by taff »

Totally off the subject, I can't seem to get straight into MF&T section of this site. There doesn't seem to be the icon at the top left hand corner of the screen that would take you into the different sections. ALL I have access to now is the general discussion section. Can someone tell me how I can access this???.

Thanks.
Doc
Guest
Guest

Post by Doc »

Ive lost the icon aswell, think its due to my firewall as I dont see the ads either.

Try clicking the bulldog top left, then going to forums in the menu on the left then MF&T will come up under the Mil fourms link. Once into it save it to your favourites. Then you have both sides, its what Ive done.

I see Beast is online so he may have a better suggestion

Doc
taff
Member
Member
Posts: 4
Joined: Tue 22 Feb, 2005 8:41 am
Location: south wales

Post by taff »

Thanks for the help Doc.

Cheers.
harry hackedoff
Member
Member
Posts: 14415
Joined: Tue 19 Feb, 2002 12:00 am

Post by harry hackedoff »

Shadders, that was your bestest, bestest, bestest ever post in the whole world, mate. 8) Hear hear :P
The whole hornet`s nest was stirred up by the News of The Screws choosing to sensationalise the vid by claiming it showed Recruits being bullied when they knew full well that wasn`t the case.
They win bigtime because the vid has gone worldwide. They are larfing their tits off, I`m sure. What`s worse is that otherwise respectable papers down here and probably elsewhere in the world, have taken the Screws version without checking the facts. I`ve had several requests that we formally complain about this barbaric practice from guys who should know better.
Just because it`s in the paper on on the telly doesn`t mean it`s true.
Besides the one guy getting snotted(which does happen ocasionally in civilian strasse I believe) it looked like a hoofing sesh, hey 8)
[url=http://www.militaryforums.co.uk/forums/groupcp.php?g=397][img]http://www.militaryforums.co.uk/forums/images/usergroups/listener.gif[/img][/url]
Post Reply