Share this page:

Draft in the US military

Interested or active in politics, discuss here.
Post Reply
Message
Author
Frank S.

Draft in the US military

#1 Post by Frank S. »

http://www.spacewar.com/2004/040420162957.57daiu50.html

Emphasis added.

Senator says US may need compulsory service to boost Iraq force,

WASHINGTON (AFP) Apr 20, 2004
A senior Republican lawmaker said Tuesday that deteriorating security in Iraq may force the United States to reintroduce the military draft.
"There's not an American ... that doesn't understand what we are engaged in today and what the prospects are for the future," Senator Chuck Hagel told a Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing on post-occupation Iraq.

"Why shouldn't we ask all of our citizens to bear some responsibility and pay some price?" Hagel said, arguing that restoring compulsory military service would force "our citizens to understand the intensity and depth of challenges we face."

The Nebraska Republican added that a draft, which was ended in the early 1970s, would spread the burden of military service in Iraq more equitably among various social strata.

"Those who are serving today and dying today are the middle class and lower middle class," he observed.

The call to consider a imposing a draft comes just days after the Pentagon moved to extend the missions of some 20,000 of the 135,000 US troops in Iraq.

Some critics of the US-led occupation complain that military planners used too few troops to subdue Iraq, and insist that more military muscle will be needed to restore order.

The US-led military coalition was put under further strain by the announcement this week by coalition members Spain and Honduras that they would withdraw their military contingents from Iraq.

Meanwhile, witnesses at the hearing, including academics and former US officials, expressed concern about ongoing flareups of violence in Iraq this month -- the bloodiest yet for US troops.

"I think it's clear that pressures in Iraq have reached the boiling point," said Samuel Berger, national security adviser during the Bill Clinton administration, who called for an increase in troops there, and a "genuine, non-grudging effort to internationalize the enterprise in Iraq, both military and civilian."

"We've got to be prepared to give up our hammerlock on decision making in exchange for genuine burden sharing."

Richard Perle, a former White House adviser who currently serves as a fellow at a conservative think tank, advised against adding troops or extending the date of handover of Iraqi sovereignty beyond the currently-set June 30 date.

"It is essential that we not delay the handover of sovereignty set for the end of June, even if there is continuing violence by those who know they have no place in a decent, democratic Iraq," he said.

Perle also warned against entrusting the United Nations with the post-occupation administration of Iraq, saying UN involvement should be kept at "an absolute minimum."

"A large UN contingent in Iraq ... would do more harm than good," Perle said.

"It would discourage the assumption of sovereignty by Iraqis themselves. It would drain resources urgently needed for the development of Iraq's economy," Perle said.


A senior Democrat meanwhile, lashed out at the White House for failing to send a top administration official to appear before the panel.

"I think it is outrageous that the administration has not provided every witness we've asked for," said Senator Joseph Biden, the highest-ranking Democrat on the committee.

"The fact that they are not prepared to send a witness means that they are either totally incompetent and they don't have anything to tell us ... or they're refusing to allow us to fulfill our constitutional responsibility" of congressional oversight, Biden said.

The committee's Republican chairman, Richard Lugar, also slammed the White House for "inadequate planning and communication related to Iraq."

Advertise your company or services here and contact us today!

Marina
Rising Star Member
Rising Star Member
Posts: 493
Joined: Wed 26 Mar, 2003 6:22 pm
Location: London

#2 Post by Marina »

This quite alarming news Frank :o

I don't think it would be implemented as there would be alot of opposition in this current political climate ?

What do you think ?

User avatar
df2inaus
Rising Star Member
Rising Star Member
Posts: 445
Joined: Sun 14 Sep, 2003 2:29 am
Location: Toronto

A return to the Draft in the US?

#3 Post by df2inaus »

Frank S,
"Why shouldn't we ask all of our citizens to bear some responsibility and pay some price?" Hagel said, arguing that restoring compulsory military service would force "our citizens to understand the intensity and depth of challenges we face."

The Nebraska Republican added that a draft, which was ended in the early 1970s, would spread the burden of military service in Iraq more equitably among various social strata.

"Those who are serving today and dying today are the middle class and lower middle class," he observed.

The call to consider a imposing a draft comes just days after the Pentagon moved to extend the missions of some 20,000 of the 135,000 US troops in Iraq.


If there was to be a draft the first thing they'd need to do is eliminate deferments for marriage and students, obviously to avoid people pulling a Clinton and causing a surge in grad school enrolments. Then the National Guard would have to establish a minimum recruiting age etc....

Perhaps instead of selective service all males aged 21 or whatever could serve for 2 years and avoid the randomness of the draft. A statistics prof once proved the biggest factor in getting drafted was the month you were born in!

Many would argue having a professional army is in itself a force-multiplier, certainly seems to be the case.
"Poor Ike, it won't be a bit like the Army. He'll find it very frustrating. He'll sit here and he'll say, 'Do this! Do that!' And nothing will happen."
Harry Truman

Frank S.

#4 Post by Frank S. »

There's another possiblity...
viewtopic.php?t=5517

In fact there are many things outside our control which could affect the draft adversely.

User avatar
Tab
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 5626
Joined: Wed 16 Apr, 2003 7:09 pm
Location: Southern England
Contact:

#5 Post by Tab »

Yes, Bring Back National Service, and this time with the equeal rights call up the girls as well.

:drinking: :drinking: :drinking: :drinking: :drinking: :drinking: :drinking: :drinking: :drinking: :drinking:

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest