MilitaryForums.co.uk

Hi,

Does anybody know if they've released the names of the 2 soldiers killed on Tuesday?

I can't find it on the BBC news site so I'm guessing they haven't. Usually they inform the families and then publish it fairly quickly.

Cheers

If they have't released their names yet, I suspect they were probably SF mate.

Their names are not going to be released at the request of their families


http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0, ... 84,00.html

There we go then Any reason you wanted to know mate?

Cheers for the info.

Just got a couple of mates out there at the moment.

they where SBS. I have a chum out there too and I shudder when ever i hear reports on the news about brits killed

I was waiting anxiously to find out if it was SF, my AFCO told me no Royal Marines had been killed since WW2, minus the helicopter crash a while back, but that wasnt his fault. I guess I expected that it would be the same story for Special Forces, evidently not. But they are up against enemies who know the territory, outnumber them and it was a planned ambush...

im not sure thats quite true.

found this just now:
http://thescotsman.scotsman.com/index.cfm?id=379292003

Hughser wrote:I was waiting anxiously to find out if it was SF, my AFCO told me no Royal Marines had been killed since WW2, minus the helicopter crash a while back, but that wasnt his fault. I guess I expected that it would be the same story for Special Forces, evidently not. But they are up against enemies who know the territory, outnumber them and it was a planned ambush...

Any soldier can be killed no matter how good they are, in fact a lot of the best soldiers are the first to die cause they're the 1st to put their lives on the line.

The guy at the AFCO is talking complete rubbish to you not only did marines die in Iraq other than the helicopter crash, the guy who was killed by friendly fire from other marines is one that springs to mind.

Has he never heard of a little war called the Falklands? or Korea? Im sure marines have died in Northern Island and Borneo and Malaya and half a dozen other shitholes over the past 60 yrs.

Anyone who tries to tell you that a unit is the best by the fact none of them has died is either an idiot or a liar.

This is real life not Hollywood real soliders get killed maimed and wounded when they get into fire fights that's just the way things are.

Or this AFCO dude thought maybe you were jittery about the dangers of the job (did you have an espresso before the meeting?) and decided to lie.

This war on terror is hard on SOF/SFpersonnel. It's gonna continue that way...

borisimo- I think that was the incident involving Marine Chris Madison, where they claimed it was enemy fire, but most of the evidence suggests that is was blue on blue.

He died as a result, there was a good documentary on it a while back.

i was a little dubious about what he said, because i thought i'd heard there had been casualties in the Falklands, but i didnt question what he had to say, although it begs to reason why bother lying. Frank, im not a coffee drinker!

hes probably said theres been no deaths to not put you off applying i feel.

This might seem a bit wrong, but might he have said it in order to test your knowledge? If he made such a claim, and you replied that you thought the truth was otherwise, then obviously your service knowledge is up to scratch enough that you are confident to question such claims?

Just a thought.

Dickie

I can see your point Dickie, i did mention to him that the PRMC video he showed me was out of date, so he may of been testing my general service knowledge to see how much research i had done.